FOLLOW US
A federal appeals court has ruled that YouTube is not obligated under U.S. copyright law to actively search its platform for infringing content beyond responding to formal takedown notices.
In a unanimous decision issued Wednesday, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit upheld a lower court ruling in favor of YouTube, rejecting claims by a Spanish film producer that the video platform must identify and remove additional unauthorized clips once it receives notice of infringement.
The panel concluded that YouTube retains protection under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, or DMCA, so long as it responds properly to takedown requests and does not turn a blind eye to specific violations brought to its attention.
“The simple accumulation of adequately addressed DMCA takedown requests alone cannot amount to red flag knowledge of other infringing activity,” the court wrote, adding that such circumstances do not strip YouTube of its safe-harbor protections.
The court also rejected the argument that a takedown request targeting one infringing video requires YouTube to remove all other uploads containing the same copyrighted material.
“This is not a plausible or workable reading of the DMCA,” the judges said, noting that the law does not impose an obligation on platforms to apply automated copyright tools universally or retroactively.
The court emphasized that YouTube’s Content ID system, which allows rights holders to detect and manage copyrighted material, is not required to be deployed automatically for all content or all users.
The lawsuit was filed in 2021 by producer Carlos Vasallo and his company, Athos Overseas Ltd. Corp., who alleged that YouTube failed to adequately prevent unauthorized uploads of his films.
Vasallo claimed that YouTube acknowledged years earlier that it could easily detect the infringing content using its Content ID technology but declined to do so unless he agreed to conditions that included revenue sharing and limits on past claims.
YouTube denied those allegations and argued that the DMCA does not require platforms to independently investigate or locate infringing material beyond what copyright owners specifically identify.
In 2023, a federal judge in Florida granted summary judgment to YouTube, finding no evidence that the company had encouraged infringement or profited from the allegedly infringing clips at issue.
The appellate court agreed, stating that copyright law places the burden of identifying infringing content on rights holders, not on online platforms acting as intermediaries.
“Because YouTube has no duty to investigate infringement beyond the specific clips identified,” the lower court correctly ruled in the company’s favor, the panel said.
The decision reinforces long-standing interpretations of the DMCA that shield online platforms from liability when they promptly comply with valid takedown notices. It also limits attempts to expand platform responsibility through litigation rather than legislation.
Attorneys for both sides declined to comment following the ruling.
Case: Athos Overseas Ltd. Corp. v. YouTube Inc. et al. Case No. 23-13156 U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit
Previous Article
Ford Drops Some Law Firms From Billing Fraud Case, Adds Obstruction Claims Against Former Knight Law Partners
Ahmed Boughalleb
Ahmed is a sales development and international trade expert with decades of experience in business, acquisitions and mergers. He writes about financial and business news with a focus on the U.S. market.
FOLLOW US Recent Posts America March 28, 2026 Tennessee School Bus Crash Leaves Two Students Dead, Community in… America March 28, 2026 Noelia Castillo Euthanasia Case Ends After Lengthy Legal Battle in… America March 28, 2026 American Airlines Flight Attendant Missing Case Takes Grim Turn in… America March 28, 2026 Bank of America Epstein Lawsuit $72.5M Settlement Reaches Turning Point… America March 28, 2026 Trump to Pay TSA Workers Amid Shutdown as Crisis Deepens… America March 28, 2026 Men’s March Madness Elite 8 Delivers High-Stakes Drama as Title… America March 28, 2026 Mike Fincke Space Medical Incident Stuns NASA as Mystery Illness… Don’t Miss It America March 28, 2026 NASA Artemis II Moon Mission Launch Nears as Historic Crew Prepares for Deep Space Gamble By – Rihem Akkouche America March 28, 2026 No Kings Protests Planned for Saturday as Nationwide Dissent Swells By – Rihem Akkouche America March 28, 2026 Goliath Ventures Filed for Chapter 11 as Alleged $328M Crypto Scheme Unravels By – Rihem Akkouche America March 27, 2026 Feds Guarantee Loans for Farmers as Industry Faces Mounting Pressures By – Rachel Moore America March 27, 2026 Grand Canyon Park Reopen North Rim After Devastating Wildfire By – Rachel Moore America March 27, 2026 UN Aviation Limits Power Bank Use in Sweeping In-Flight Safety Shift By – Rachel Moore America March 27, 2026 Ohio State Suspends Fraternity After Student Hospitalization By – Rachel Moore America March 27, 2026 Iran FBI Director Email Hack Sparks Cybersecurity Alarm and Global Tensions By – Rihem Akkouche Also on usaherald-com- Business
- Health
- Sports
In what appears as a desperate attempt to defend multiple allegations of fraud on the courts, the Kelly Warner Law…
Arizona January 4, 2025 Aaron Kelly Law Firm Resorts To Attacking Former Client Again On KellyWarnerLaw.com – Pattern RecognizedAttorney Aaron Kelly and his law partner Daniel Warner are currently under investigation by the Arizona Bar for legal misconduct.…
Arizona December 12, 2024 Arizona Bar Opens Investigation on Attorney Aaron KellyUSA Herald recently reported on a developing story involving Attorneys Daniel Warner and Aaron Kelly. Both Warner and Kelly have…
America March 27, 2026 Jill Biden Agent Shooting Sparks Security Probe at Philadelphia AirportThe incident now widely referred to as the jill biden agent shooting unfolded in seconds—but its shockwaves are rippling far…
America March 27, 2026 US Delay Ukraine Weapons Shipments Raises Alarm Across NATO AlliesThe issue of US delay Ukraine weapons shipments is stirring unease among Western allies, casting a shadow over a carefully…
America March 27, 2026 Nexstar-Tegna Media Merger Lawsuit Ignites Political Firestorm and Courtroom BattleThe Nexstar-Tegna media merger lawsuit is rapidly becoming more than a legal dispute—it’s unfolding like a high-stakes chess match where…
America March 27, 2026 Tourist Helicopter Crashes in Kauai Leave Trail of Tragedy on Remote ShoreA tourist helicopter plunged onto a remote stretch of sand along Hawaii’s rugged coastline, turning a scenic journey into a…
America March 27, 2026 Senate Vote on DHS Shutdown Ends Weeks-Long StandoffThe Senate vote on DHS shutdown unfolded in the early hours of Friday, bringing a dramatic pause to a 42-day…
America March 27, 2026 Eight Stunning Beaches Around the WorldFrom remote Italian coves to Tasmanian white sands, BBC reporters highlight beaches that offer more than just sun and surf.…
America March 27, 2026 Eight Stunning Beaches Around the WorldFrom remote Italian coves to Tasmanian white sands, BBC reporters highlight beaches that offer more than just sun and surf.…
America March 27, 2026 Key Exports at Risk Beyond Oil as Hormuz Disruption Ripples GloballyThe disruption of oil and gas flows through the Strait of Hormuz, triggered by the US-Israel conflict with Iran, has…
America March 27, 2026 Nvidia Bets Big on AI Agents With New Tools, Hardware PushNvidia, the world’s most valuable company and a central force behind the artificial intelligence surge, is doubling down on AI…
America March 27, 2026 New Therapies Offer Hope for Lasting Relief From Hay FeverA new generation of treatments is renewing hopes that seasonal allergies could one day be controlled at their source, rather…
America March 27, 2026 Five Practical Ways Parents Can Curb Kids’ Endless ScrollingA recent U.S. court decision finding that Meta and Google deliberately engineered addictive social media platforms has resonated with many…
America March 27, 2026 Jury Verdict Against Social Media Giants Signals Turning Point for Tech IndustryA Los Angeles jury has issued a sweeping judgment against two of the world’s most widely used digital platforms, Instagram…
America March 25, 2026 7 Year-Old Girl Dies in Modesto Duplex Fire, Family DevastatedThe 7 year-old girl dies in Modesto duplex fire tragedy has left a California community reeling after flames tore through…
America March 24, 2026 Namibia Blocks Elon Musk’s Starlink in Licensing SetbackIn a move that underscores the collision between global ambition and local policy, Namibia blocks Elon Musk’s Starlink, denying the…
America March 24, 2026 NASA Plan for Moon Base Shifts Course in $20 Billion Lunar PivotIn a dramatic strategic overhaul, the NASA plan for moon base is taking center stage as the agency abandons its…
America March 24, 2026 Dayton Webber Charged With Murder After Deadly Car ShootingA story once defined by resilience and triumph has taken a dark and shocking turn, as Dayton Webber charged with…
America March 24, 2026 US Park Police Officer Shot in DC Sparks Intense ManhuntA violent ambush in the nation’s capital has triggered alarm after a US Park Police officer shot in DC during…
America March 24, 2026 Explosion at Valero Refinery Sends Smoke Towering Over Texas CoastA thunderous blast at a Gulf Coast facility has ignited concern after an Explosion at Valero refinery sent massive plumes…
America March 15, 2026 Arizona Man Accused of Crucifying Pastor Pushes Judge For A Quick Death SentenceBy Samuel A. Lopez | USA Herald – An Arizona courtroom is now the center of a deeply disturbing case…
America March 11, 2026 Trump’s Laser Talk Sparks New Questions About America’s Secret ArsenalPresident Donald Trump has once again done what he often does best in moments of war and tension: he dropped…
America March 8, 2026 The Northern Lights ReturnThe Northern Lights have a chance to be visible from several northern U.S. states on Tuesday night, forecasters at the…
America March 8, 2026 February Unemployment Up as Job Losses Surprise EconomistsFebruary Unemployment Up as the latest labor market data revealed weaker-than-expected job growth and a slight increase in the national…
America March 8, 2026 Late-Night Attack by Venezuelan National at Florida BeachA Late-night attack by a Venezuelan National has left a Florida community shaken after authorities say a 26-year-old man ambushed…
America March 8, 2026 Trump’s War in Iran: Congress Confronts Escalation After U.S. StrikesTrump’s War in Iran was triggered open conflict, casualties, and renewed constitutional debate in Washington. The crisis intensified following reports…
America March 27, 2026 Judge Blocks Pentagon Move to Halt Anthropic Tools Amid Legal FightA federal judge has handed an early legal victory to artificial intelligence firm Anthropic in its dispute with the Pentagon.…
America March 26, 2026 Chilling Pattern Emerges As Scientists with Nuclear, Exoplanet & UFO Ties Vanish or Die Amid Trump’s Disclosure Push[USA HERALD] – On February 20, 2026, President Trump posted on Truth Social directing the Pentagon and other agencies to…
America March 26, 2026 America’s Eyes On The Sky – Citizen Astronomers Step Up As Government Silence Raises Space Defense QuestionsInside this report When official channels go quiet, the sky doesn’t. And increasingly, it’s not government agencies—but ordinary citizens—who are…
America March 26, 2026 Texas Home Pierced by Meteorite As Fireball Surge Sparks Nationwide Alarm[USA HERALD] – A cantaloupe-sized space rock smashed through a Houston-area roof on March 21, 2026, ricocheted through a bedroom,…
America March 26, 2026 Taylor Frankie Paul Video Exposes Uncomfortable Truth About Female-Perpetrated Domestic Violence[USA HERALD] – A leaked 2023 video showing reality star Taylor Frankie Paul as the aggressor in a physical confrontation…
America March 26, 2026 White House Unveils National AI Policy to Guide CongressThe White House on Friday introduced its long-awaited national artificial intelligence framework, aiming to prevent individual states from enacting their…
America March 26, 2026 Counting Calories Isn’t Enough, Experts Say: Focus on How and When You EatThe conventional wisdom of weight management—balancing calories consumed with calories burned—may oversimplify how our bodies process food. Research now suggests…
America March 14, 2026 War Insurance Reality Americans Face Even When the Battlefield Is OverseasBy Samuel A. Lopez | USA Herald – When Americans hear news of airstrikes in the Persian Gulf, naval confrontations…
America March 13, 2026 Supreme Court Asked To Step In As 98-Year-Old Federal Judge Pauline Newman Fights Suspension From The Bench[USA HERALD] – For more than four decades, one of the most influential judges in American patent law helped shape…
America March 12, 2026 Iran Appears To Have Conducted Its First Major Cyberattack Against A U.S. Company, Since The War Began – New Front Opens Against American HealthcareAn alleged Iran-linked cyberattack on Stryker appears to mark a dangerous turn in the conflict, pushing digital retaliation from nuisance-level…
America March 12, 2026 Beyond Gas Prices The Strait of Hormuz Crisis Could Hit Fertilizer, Plastics, Aluminum And Global Supply ChainsBy Samuel Lopez | USA Herald – Right now, most Americans hearing about the Strait of Hormuz are thinking about…
America February 21, 2026 When The Files Are Finally Unsealed The Most Mind-Bending Truth May Not Be What We Expect[USA HERALD] – There is a widespread assumption that if governments release their most highly classified files related to unidentified…
America March 12, 2026 The World Cup Security Reckoning: Trump Warns Iran Soccer Team About Safety As War Tensions Spill Into Global SportsBy Samuel A. Lopez | USA Herald – A short Truth-Social post from President Donald Trump on Thursday morning is now…
America March 8, 2026 Trump’s War in Iran: Congress Confronts Escalation After U.S. StrikesTrump’s War in Iran was triggered open conflict, casualties, and renewed constitutional debate in Washington. The crisis intensified following reports…
America March 1, 2026 Cadillac Names Inaugural Formula 1 Car MAC-26 in Tribute to Mario Andretti Ahead of 2026 Australian Grand Prix DebutCadillac has officially revealed the name of its first Formula 1 challenger, confirming that its 2026 car will be called…
By – Ahmed Boughalleb
America February 20, 2026 Norway Tops Medal Table After Day 13 at 2026 Winter Olympics as Team USA Surges Into Second PlaceWith 13 days complete at the 2026 Milan Cortina Winter Olympics, Norway sits atop the overall medal standings, collecting 34…
By – Ahmed Boughalleb
America February 18, 2026 Olympic Science Explained: How Figure Skaters Spin at Blinding Speeds Without Getting DizzyWhen Amber Glenn finishes her routine, the arena usually rises with her. The music builds, her blades carve a tight…
America February 16, 2026 Olympic Villages Run Out of Condoms at 2026 Milan-Cortina GamesCondom supplies in the Olympic Villages at the 2026 Winter Games have been temporarily depleted, the Milan-Cortina organizing committee confirmed,…
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Cancel replySignup for the USA Herald exclusive Newsletter
We are The People's Media. USA Herald covers everything from breaking news to investigative journalism. We also report on politics on the State and National level